This article should answer most questions that you will have regarding incompetent cervixes and the different cervical cerclage procedures. It includes pictures and links to additional reading material.
Incompetent Cervix and Cerclage Procedures
What
is an Incompetent Cervix?
An incompetent cervix is one that opens prematurely under the stress of
the growing uterus and occurs in about 2 percent of all pregnancies. It
is believed that cervical incompetence is the cause of 20-25 % of all second
trimester losses. Most miscarriages/preterm labors happen during weeks 16-24
of the pregnancy. Although, an overwhelming majority of the women on our
message boards who reported having miscarriages due to an incompetant cervix,
reported miscarrying at around 20 weeks gestation.
How
is an Incompetent Cervix diagnosed? Unfortunately, most incompetant
cervixes are only known about due to a prior miscarriage due to the same
thing. However, your doctor may catch this if your cervix begins to open
and thin prematurely, usually during the second trimester. A pregnant woman
with an incompetant cervix may complain of contractions comparable in pain
to prelabor contractions. Currently, transvaginal ultrasound is being used
to measure the length of the cervix in an attempt to diagnose this condition
sooner, so that a cerclage can be placed before a pregnancy loss.
Why doesn't
everyone who has had a preterm birth get a cerclage? There are many
causes of preterm birth. Cervical cerclages only help those women who have
abnormal cervixes. Even with a cerclage, a preterm birth can occur or other
problems can arise. A woman who has had a cerclage will be monitored more
frequently throughout her pregnancy for symptoms of infection and premature
labour.
Who
is at risk for an Incompetant Cervix? Although the causes are unknown,
you may be at risk for an incompetant cervix if you have had:
- D&C's (dilation & curettage) for abortion, miscarriage, or other
reasons.
- Previous pregnancy loss in the second trimester.
- Surgery on your cervix.
- Multiple pregnancy terminations.
- Damage to the cervix from a previous birth.
- Are the daughter of a woman who took DES, a hormone used to prevent miscarriages.
Who may not be considered for a cerclage if they are at risk?
It is likely that you will not be considered for a cervical cerclage if:
- You have hyperirritability of the cervix.
- Your baby has already died.
- You are more than 4 cm dilated.
- Your water is broken.
What
can be done to help me carry my baby to term? Generally, a cerclage will
be done and has an 85%-95% success rate, depending on the doctor -
the average success rate is 85% (1997, 200 cerclages). Another alternative
would be strict bedrest; I am unsure of the success rate for complete bedrest.
What
is a Cerclage? A cerclage is when they stitch your cervix closed to
help keep it from dialating prematurely because the cervix is too weak to
hold in a pregnancy to term. Cerclage can help prevent a second trimester
miscarriage or preterm delivery by keeping the cervix closed. A series of
stitches are placed around the cervix and tightened. They use suture on
the cervix and tie it like a purse string and pull it tight.
3
Most Common Types of Cerclages:
-
Vaginal
Cervical Cerclage: McDonald Stitch:
Placement: A
McDonald stitch is best described as a piece of "tape"
placed vaginally, at the level of the internal cervical
os (where the lower uterine segment and cervix meet). The
bladder must be mobilized (disseced out of the way) for
the stitch to be placed in the correct position. McDonalds
are considered easier to do than Shirodkars and are usually
used when there is significant effacement of the lower portion
of the cervix. The
McDonald cerclage is removed in the office at 37 weeks to
allow vaginal delivery -- it must be replaced with each
pregnancy. You will not need an anesthetic when the stitch
is removed and you may go into labor directly after the
removal, or it may take as long as 2-3 weeks. It is shown
that this stitch has very little impact of the chances for
having a vaginal delivery.
- Vaginal
Cervical Cerclage: Shirodkar Stitch (see Figure 2.):
Placement:
A Shirodkar stitch is a suture inserted into the cervix at 4 points,
then tied. Abdominal cerclages are placed vaginally, at the level
of the internal cervical os (where the lower uterine segment and
cervix meet). The bladder must
be mobilized (disseced out of the way) for the stitch to be placed
in the correct position. Shirodkars
are considered more difficult to do than the McDonald stitch. Sometimes
a Shirodkar is removed, but is sometimes left in throughout the
length of the pregnancy and a c-section is done. You
will not need an anesthetic when the stitch is removed and you may
go into labor directly after the removal, or it may take as long
as 2-3 weeks. The reason that there is conflicting explanations
regarding the Shirodkar cerclage is that it used to be a permanent
stitch that was kept in and required a c-section, but a modified
version hassince been applied by doctors which allows for removal
and vaginal delivery
|
Fig 1. Cervical Cerclage.

|
Fig 2. Shirodkar Stitch.

|
|
|
3. Abdominal Cerclage: Transabdominal Cervical
Cerclage (TCC,TCIC):
The transabdominal cerclage is done via a c-section type incision
(either Pfannenstiel or Cherney) and requires a c-section for delivery.
According to Fred Coleman, MD, an abdominal cerclage is usually put
in after a pregnancy has begun but can also be put in between pregnancies.
Most of Dr. Novy's patients undergo a transabdominal cerclage at 11-13
weeks gestation, after an ultrasound has provided supporting evidence
of a viable fetus. It is usually not tight enough to prevent a D&C
if you miscarry. Once an abdominal cerclage has been placed, it is
not removed, even after the pregnancy is over, and can be used for
subsequent pregnancies.
"Downsides apart form the pain is that you have
to have a c section; it is a little uncomfortable throughout
pregnancy; I had to have bedrest as if I stood or sat up
for too long I would start contracting. But it has a success
rate of something like 95% and we have a wonderful baby
to prove it.
My surgeon had placed 35 TCCs by the time he did mine:
only one mum lost her baby, but she (and many others) went
on to have successful pregnancies." ~Jane
Laura Smith (2/24/02).
"After
I had the surgery [transabdominal] they made me wait 3 months
before trying to get pregnant." ~Kara
(1/15/03)
|
If a cerclage closes my cervix, then what happens if... I have
a miscarriage and need a D&C or have a transabdominal and have a period
or want sperm to "get in" so that I can get pregnant in the
first place? The stitch is not stitched so tight that your cervix is completely
closed. This should not be a problem.
Are
any of the cerclages more effective? Both the McDonald and Shirokdar
cervical cerclages are equally effective, but if the cervix is too short
to hold a vaginal cerclage, or if a vaginal cerclage has failed in the
past, then the transabdominal cerclage is preferred. Many women who have
had previous vaginal stitches fail, have carried their babies to term
using the transabdominal cervical cerclage.
Anesthesia
and Cerclages? "No doses of any anesthetic are proven safe for first
trimester pregnancy. Therefore I use the smallest dose of the fewest drugs:
spinal anesthesia with no sedation." ~Steve Schrenzel MD. Most of the
time, a spinal or epideral is given. Occassionally, you may be given the
"asleep" medication.
Tell me
more about the procedure: You will probably be asked not to eat the
night before the surgery. You will likely be admitted into the hospital
and given an anesthetic, usually an epideral. The operation will last
about an hour. Your baby's heartbeat will probably be checked both before
and after the surgery. You baby may even be monitored via ultrasound during
the surgery. After surgery, you will be monitored to make sure that you
don't go into preterm labor because of the surgery possibly agitating
your uterus to contract. You may have a small amount of bleeding and/or
cramping after the procedure; ask your doctor what is normal. You may
be given medication to prevent infection or contractions. You will probably
spend 12-24 hours in the hospital, although this is not always the case.
You will also probably be given bedrest for the first few days following
the surgery. Most women who had a cerclage surgery felt "back to
normal" within 2 weeks post-op.
RISKS
of having a CERVICAL CERCAGE (Taken from a Cervical Cerclage Patient Consent
Form):
Complications
from this procedure are rare, but sometimes occur.
-
Complications
could cause the need to undergo another cervical cerclage.
-
It
is possible that this operation will not help you.
-
There
is also a possibility that your current condition will worsen after surgery.
-
As
in any surgical procedure, bleeding and infection are potential complications
of cervical cerclage for incompetent cervix.
-
These
complications can cause prolonged illness, the need for blood transfusions
and even permanent disability.
-
Although,
perforation or puncture of the uterus is rare, this complication can cause
pelvic bleeding and infection, and even bleeding and infection inside
the belly.
-
Very
Rare: Rupture of the cervix, premature delivery or miscarriage or abortion,
blood clots in the legs, pelvis, and lungs.
-
Extremely
rare: Allergic or other bad reactions to one or more of the substances
used in the procedure.
-
Some
of the complications of this operation may require further surgery
-
Some
complications could potentially result in sterility or the inability to
bear or have children.
-
Very
rarely, some of the complications can even be fatal.
" I had severe contractions after surgery and lost my mucus plug.
The surgery irritated my uterus, and I have had contractions ever since.
I am on bedrest and oral meds around the clock. I am also on a home uterine
monitoring system. The good news is that I have made it to 27 weeks! Though
this pregnancy has been difficult, I finally feel like everything is going
to be alright. My contractions have decreased signifigantly (from 9 to
3 every hour). I don't think that another pregnancy would be as difficult
since the cerclage is already in place." ~susanmaried
(4/22/02).
Complications
can result from Abdominal Cerclages as well.
- Infrequently, fetal death, intrauterine growth retardation, suture migration,
premature rupture of the membranes, placental abruption, and excessive blood
loss.
- Rarely, a possible loss of your uterus.
"Unfortunately, I lost my baby on the operating table. The
doctor did not know if it was the stress of surgery [abdominal cerclage]
or a miscarriage that would have happened regardless. I now have the
cerclage in place and am working with a fertility specialist to try
and get pregnant again. Despite the enormous heartbreak of losing
my first baby -- I truely believe that I have a very good chance at
going to term with the abdominal cerclage in place." ~kzfuller
(2/23/02).
After
Cervical Cerclage Operation, your doctor may recommend:
- 12-24 hours after surgery, you will be on bedrest and monitored for possible
preterm labor.
- Your doctor may recommend that you lie on your left side twice daily or
may even restrict you to total bedrest.
- On some occasions, antibiotics will be given to prevent infection.
- Nothing is allowed inside vagina after the procedure (no douching either).
- You will asked to abstain from sexual intercourse (at least until 24-26
weeks).
- Because breast stimulation causes contractions, you will be asked to abstain.
- You may have to abstain from strenuous activity including heavy lifting.
- You may be scheduled for a follow-up visit in 1 week.
- Your physical activity may be restricted, including heavy housework and
frequent stairs.
- You may have more frequent prental visits - possibly every 1-3 weeks to
have your cervix checked.
Of
transabdominal cerclage while pregnant: "The surgery is
painful--I had morphine for 48 hours and could not sit up, or walk,
unaided for 4 days. Far worse than a cesarian section. I had to
take indomehtacin until week 23 as I kept on contracting. But it
worked, and the suture is still there so if we want another baby
I won't need the surgery again." ~Jane
Laura Smith (2/24/02).
Of transabdominal cerclage: "My operation went without
incident, it was only as painful as a C section for me and I was
up and around in 2 or 3 days." ~Lynne
(11/26/02).
Of vaginal cerclage: "When I have the cerclage put in,
I have to be on strict bedrest like I am now. This is my third child...There
are a lot of downfalls like bedrest and lots of weight gain, it
even hurts bad when the stitch gets pulled out and you can feel
the scab aroud it. With my second, I got a mild yeast infection
because a piece of stitching was lost in my cervix. But... when
I look at my kids and feel this one moving, it is definately worth
the trouble." ~nappere1osuedu
(12/27/02).
Of transabdominal cerclage before pregnancy: "My Dr. told
me that because I was fit I would be feeling back to normal within
2 weeks and he was right. I was even back to work within 2 weeks
after the surgery." ~Kara
(12/31/02).
Of the vaginal cerclage: "My experience with the vaginal
cerclage was not painful at all. They put me under and then did
the procedure." ~Sandra
(1/16/03).
Of the vaginal cerclage: "I had a spinal and didn't feel
anything but pressure but that didn't bother me either. I could
tell each time she did the stitch and when she tightend it in the
end. But I didn't actually "feel" it. I could see my body
move. I did have some pain after everything wore off and I was on
my way home from the hospital. But once I urinated the pain went
away. I guess it was because of the pressure. I am now a week later
and I feel great. It doesn't feel like I even have a stitch in."
~Karen
(12/13/00).
- Symptoms of Preterm Labor
- Cramping
- Lower back pain
- Contractions of tightenings
- Pressure in lower back, abdomen, or thighs
- Increase or change in vaginal discharge
- Leaking of fluids or breaking of bag of waters.
- A temperature above 100 F (38 C) degrees.
- Vaginal bleeding or spotting
- Chills.
- Nausea and vomiting.
- A bad-smelling vaginal discharge.
What if my "bag of waters" breaks while I have a cerclage
in? "There
are a few studies dealing with the risk-benefit of leaving or removing
the cervical cerclage in a women presenting with PROM. Evidence from small
numbers of patients suggests that retaining cerclage is associated with
increased latency time, but also with a remarkably higher risk for fetal
infection and perinatal mortality. Therefore, on the basis of available
evidence, it seems reasonable to remove cerclage in these women."
-From http://www.med.uni-giessen.de/entog/premature.htm.
What about removal of the stitches? If you had a trans-vaginal
cerclage (either McDonald or Shirokdar), then you will either have your
stitches removed at around 37 weeks or during labor. Once the stitches
are removed, you will probably go into labor right away, but it may take
up to 2-3 weeks. If you had a trans-abdominal cerclage, you can leave
your stitches in for life or have abdominal surgery to remove the sutures.
"I just had my cerclage removed last week and am awaiting
the arrival of my daughter. I felt every little pressure ten times worse,
but my doctor said that this was normal." ~ncabeen
(3/27/01).
Do you have a specific
question about high-risk pregnancies?
Or just want to chat with other pregnant moms?
High-Risk
Pregnancy
Keywords: incompetent, incompetant, cervix, cervex, IC, PROM
IC, trans-vaginal, TCC, TCIC, lash stitch
|